It is the opposite of A Better World, and it requires the player to save all possible characters in the game. It cannot be earned by choosing the "No Save" option, therefore saving a character and quitting the chapter, and then jumping to the next chapter to save another character will not work. All of the characters must be saved in a single playthrough. Saving all of these characters will grant the trophy.
Characters to be saved
- Walter and Jimmy in the chapter Homeless. During the burning building scene, it is required to save them by freeing Walter and possessing Jimmy.
- Paul in the chapter Navajo. Ignore the ritual and rush to his room; use Aiden to heal him.
- Norah Gray in the chapter Norah. Leave the room, and do not use Aiden to stop her heart.
- Cole Freeman and Ryan Clayton in the chapter Black Sun. To save Cole, you need to carry him to the elevator and use Aiden to heal him, while to save Ryan, you must make Nathan Dawkins see that what he's doing is wrong. He will then commit suicide rather than kill Ryan who wishes to sacrifice himself to protect Jodie.